Save 15% with our Anniversary Offer!

Café Américain is celebrating one year of challenging the New Normal with bold writing.

To mark the occasion, we’re offering a special deal, valid until May 5th.

Join now for full access to all articles, and use code CA-ANNIVERSARY at checkout to enjoy 15% off your first annual membership payment!

Black Coffee Friday – 20% Off Subscriptions!

Now is the time to save money while reading your best (and longest) weekend commentary on current society, politics, and culture. Valid from November 14 to December 12, 2025.

Join now for full access to all articles, and use code BLACK-COFFEE-FRIDAY at checkout to enjoy 20% off your annual membership!

Briefly on Long Covid

When Is a Disease Real?
Ferdinand Hodler, 'Valentine Godé-Darel on Her Sickbed' (1914)
Ferdinand Hodler, 'Valentine Godé-Darel on Her Sickbed' (1914)

As is probably true of most who opposed the Covid response, I have a response of visceral anger and disgust to the phrase “Long Covid”. Of course, I detest the word “Covid” on its own, but back in the heyday of the response, “Long Covid” felt like the icing on the cake, or rather the extra layer of shit on the shit sandwich.

Long Covid seemed so objectionable because it was yet another weapon in the arsenal of arguments to prove that Covid was an unprecedented, unthinkable menace, necessitating the indefinite shutdown of society. Worse still, Long Covid was reeled out as a way to revive fear when ordinary Covid was starting to seem less terrifying. True, on the surface, Covid might be little more than a headache and the sniffles. But there was always, even with the mildest cases, the lurking threat of Long Covid, its length and possible depredations unknown, and thereby all the more awful. Sniffles and headache could be followed—for all The Science knew—by a lifetime of crippling illness. All the more reason to stay home, stay safe, and in due course get the shots.

Long Covid was reeled out as a way to revive fear when ordinary Covid was starting to seem less terrifying.

In this sense, Long Covid truly was a tool of public health terrorism, and detestable as such. It could also be critiqued on less purely political grounds. As a disease entity, Long Covid was particularly poorly defined: the list of symptoms was hopelessly long, and the condition was not sharply distinguishable from the generally widespread phenomenon of making a slow and painful recovery from a bad bout of influenza-like illness. Yet, within the overall feeding frenzy of Covid research, excessive funding was going towards finding Long Covid treatments, although it was clearly dubious that anything of worth would emerge from this expenditure. Long Covid was also embraced with unsavory enthusiasm by influencers riding the wave of public health hysteria, while it was notorious that some Long Covid sufferers who received prominent media attention had never even tested positive for Covid. Last but not least, there was no good way of distinguishing the suffering reported as Long Covid from the natural consequences of the isolation and terror brought on by lockdowns and forced vaccination: how could these not cause prolonged pain of mind and body for millions?

The suffering named “Long Covid” was hardly imaginary.

Half a decade later, all these objections stand up fairly well, as far as they go. However they will not do full justice to Long Covid, if they are to prompt a determination that the condition was and is “not real”. In practice, such a position would require telling anyone claiming to have suffered from Long Covid that their condition was imaginary, and that they were deluded. In some cases, such a blunt statement might do some good. But many could reasonably respond that “Long Covid” was how they named and understood something very real and painful which they had endured. Of course, their suffering itself was hardly imaginary, and what would be gained by telling them they had given it the wrong name and aetiology, particularly if one had no clear alternative to propose?

At this stage, it is helpful to use an idea often elaborated by tireless lockdown critic Medical Nemesis, namely that diseases are not really entities at all, but rather practices. Diseases are not things that exist independently in nature, or that happen to us, but things that we do. This is true of Covid itself, which only existed at the intersection of laboratory science, political action, bodily suffering and death, and the stories that we told about those things. Each influenced the others, and as each of them has changed, so the meaning of “Covid” has itself shifted: Covid today simply is not what it was in 2020-21, and the chief reason for this is not because we now have vaccines or understand Covid better, or Covid is no longer a “novel disease”, but because how we do Covid has changed so drastically. The lockdowns and vaccine mandates and tests and emergency messaging are all faded or gone, and so the practice of Covid is now barely distinguishable from that of all that we call “the flu”.

This downgrading in how we practice Covid has meant that Long Covid too has now largely disappeared, although of course it retains some devotees. But it does not follow that Long Covid was never real in the first place. Rather, Long Covid was very real precisely as a practice, as a way that patients, doctors, reporters and so forth acted in conjunction in certain circumstances. Bodily suffering was certainly part of this nexus, but that suffering’s nature and quality cannot be separated from the other elements.

In this perspective, “Was Long Covid real?” is the wrong question. We ought rather to ask what the practice of Long Covid meant to those who engaged in it. To this there cannot be a single, universal answer. Certainly, for some, it meant enforcement of the Covid response, exerted on others or on themselves. For others, it offered the scientific gloss they needed to believe their suffering was justified. For many, perhaps, it was little more than a name to give to the breakdown of body and soul brought on by those years of darkness. In truth, few of us escaped that darkness unscathed, so that Long Covid has in a way proven far more real and more dangerous than Covid itself.